Are Light Weights Better For Building Muscle Than Heavy Weights?

Can you build muscle with light weights?

Lose Weight / October 28, 2023

Photo Credit Getty Images

Gretchen Reynolds on the science of fitness.

Upending conventions about how best to strength train, a new study finds that people who lift relatively light weights can build just as much strength and muscle size as those who grunt through sessions using much heftier weights — if they plan their workouts correctly.

In traditional weight training programs, in fact, we are told to first find the heaviest amount of weight that we possibly can lift one time. This is our one-repetition maximum weight. We then use this to shape the rest of the program by lifting 80 to 90 percent of that amount eight to 10 times, until our affected arms or legs shake with fatigue.

This approach to weight training is very effective, says Stuart Phillips, a professor of kinesiology at McMaster University in Hamilton, Ontario, who has long studied muscles and exercise. It builds muscle strength and size, possibly, many experts believe, by sparking a surge in the body’s production of testosterone and human growth hormone.

But many people find lifting such heavy weights to be daunting or downright unpleasant, which can discourage them from taking up or continuing with a resistance-training program, Dr. Phillips says.

So in recent years, he and his colleagues have been looking into the effects of a different type of weight training, which employs much lighter weights hefted through as many as 25 repetitions.

Since 2010, his lab has published several studies in which volunteers followed either the traditional regimen using heavy weights or an alternative that employed much slighter weight stacks. In general, the lifters’ results were comparable.

But those studies had been small and featured volunteers who were new to the gym, potentially skewing the outcomes, Dr. Phillips says. Almost everyone who takes up weight training shows significant improvements in strength and muscle size, making it difficult to tease out the impacts of one version of training versus another.

So for the new study, which was funded by the Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada and, he and his colleagues recruited 49 young men who had been weight training for a year or more. (The scientists plan to study women and older people in future studies.)

All completed tests of strength, fitness, hormone levels and muscular health, then were randomly divided into two groups.

One group was assigned to follow the standard regimen, in which weights were set at between 75 and 90 percent of the man’s one-repetition maximum and the volunteer lifted until he could not lift again, usually after about 10 repetitions.

The other volunteers began the lighter routine. Their weights were set at between 30 and 50 percent of each man’s one-repetition maximum, and he lifted them as many as 25 times, until the muscles were exhausted.

All of the volunteers performed three sets of their various lifts four times per week for 12 weeks.

Then they returned to the lab to have muscle strength, size and health reassessed and their hormone levels re-measured.

The results were unequivocal. There were no significant differences between the two groups. All of the men had gained muscle strength and size, and these gains were almost identical, whether they had lifted heavy or light weights.

Interestingly, the scientists found no connection between changes in the men’s hormone levels and their gains in strength and muscle size. All of the men had more testosterone and human growth hormone flowing through their bodies after the workouts. But the degree of those changes in hormone levels did not correlate with their gains in strength.

Instead, the key to getting stronger for these men, Dr. Phillips and his colleagues decided, was to grow tired. The volunteers in both groups had to attain almost total muscular fatigue in order to increase their muscles’ size and strength.

That finding suggests, Dr. Phillips says, that there is something about the cellular mechanisms jump-started in muscle tissue by exhaustion that enables you to develop arms like the first lady’s.

This data does not prove, though, that one approach to lifting weights is necessarily better than the other, Dr. Phillips says.

“But some people will find it much easier or less intimidating” to lift lighter weights, he says, even though they need to complete more repetitions in order to tire their muscles. They also may experience fewer injuries, he says, although that possibility has not yet been tested.

For now, someone hoping to strengthen his or her muscles should choose a weight that feels tolerable and then lift it repeatedly until the effort of the final lift is at least an eight on a scale of one to 10, Dr. Phillips says. “There should be some discomfort, ” he says, “but the dividends on the back side” in terms of stronger, healthier muscles “are enormous.”

How to apply eyeliner? What does pw mean? What does nebulous mean? what do you put for special skills on a job application What does spirit animal mean? Why are the tips of my fiddle leaf tree browning? what is the definition of title card What time does st4 come out? how to improve hospital readmission rates according to his advice to the google employees, what should corporations give to charity? How are carnival tips split among the crew? what is the difference between rachio 3 and 3e what is the difference between assisted living and nursing home What does short selling stock mean? What is the meaning of the 7th amendment? how to improve my reading level and comprehension what advice did jethro give moses .edu What the meaning of circumstances? what is the definition of workplace harassment What does it mean when your poop is dark green? what is mental telepathy definition how to improve it infrastructure What the tips of your hair will look like from diferen angels with 3 color dyes? How to upload songs to spotify? who changed herd immunity definition how was davy crockett being sarcastic on advice to politicians john derbyshire article "advice on how to stay safe" what advice would you give a friend who doesn't understand downsizing What earphone tips work with jaybird x3? How to make meat loaf? How to prevent tonsil stones? What does purple heart emoji mean? what is a persuasive essay definition swtor if i make a free 60, what crew skills do i get What does torrid mean? How to make sausage and peppers? how to write a memo of advice what are the benefits of a college education What does it mean when you fart a lot? what the difference between ethereum and ethereum classic why do people get life advice from quotes How to unlike something on facebook? How do dogs do tricks by looking at pictures? what are the benefits of nutmeg essential oil Movie where he tricks the infrared? What does indited meaning law? What are biceps? when to expect p ebt benefits 2021 How to store dry ice? What is the meaning of gaslighting in a relationship? what is the difference between ptsd and cptsd how to measure garage door torsion springs How to do a split? if i don't have any skills how can i make a resume What does mlf mean? what is the difference between sale pending and under contract How to reheat pulled pork? how to delete free advice account how to improve front squat where can i post advice about relationships What does 420 mean in slang? Tips when booking sandals? What is the meaning of pansexual? what is a key difference in the purpose of the articles by susan glaspell and midnight assassin? How to stop having nightmares? what is the definition of falling action in a story How to get strep throat? What is chitlins? what is the difference between an estimator and an estimate? How to get rid of dark spots from acne? who to talk to for financial advice What does mhm mean texting? How to get gallade? what is the definition of an official language how to improve olfactory senses how can i improve my acting skills What is jedi mind tricks' character? what is a contract for difference Cat gender how to tell pictures? How to fix stiff neck? what is the definition of disabled person How to record your screen windows 10? which of the following is the best sociological definition of income? course hero why if helper t disabled makes one vulnerable to secondary infections. what is the difference between permeability and porosity What are snickerdoodles? what is permanent partial disability benefits what is a straight loan definition what is the difference between external and internal what is stanzas definition What are all the branches of the military? what does milliliters measure how to delete wii usb helper 10-tips-on-how-to? how to learn a pumper skills How long to cook thin pork chops in oven? why interpersonal skills are important to managers at all levels What are you doing in italian? what are the benefits of taking amino acids What does mustard gas do? what is the definition of sonar how do you measure bmi What does dolo mean? Tips for when you are getting your blood pressure checked? How to get permanent marker out of clothes? What is the meaning of lmao in tagalog? what is good advice for someone just getting a credit card How to restart mac? what is the definition of spatial inequality what is the difference between robust tomato and hearty marinara What does graft mean? what are the health benefits of chicory root what is the difference between real and nominal gdp? How to pronounce a word? what is the nec definition of a qualified person who advice on omicron un security council how to get resolutions definition how many use lol helper How to clean chrome tailpipe tips? What does closeout mean? What is the meaning of hearth? What medicines are blood thinners? which is the best definition of a conic section apex What does mace taste like? How to bake acorn squash? What does it mean if i dream about my ex? what is the difference between toyota prius 1-2-3-4-5 What time does dodger stadium open? What does correspondence mean? how to thicken a sauce chicken helper How long does accutane take to work? How to freeze corn? what is advice on parents paying off uk student loan What does conductor mean? what skills are needed to be a personal trainer Why does our mind plays tricks on us? Tricks of the trade: how to think about your research while doing it pdf? Professional how to write a resignation letter? What is meaning of ugly? What does it mean to get tips at nail salon? How old do you have to be to smoke weed? How to delete apps on mac? What does innovative mean? what is the difference between uber connect and uberx what is the difference between the two covid-19 vaccines What does rfi stand for? What time does game of thrones air on hbo go? what is the difference between burrata and mozzarella Tips how to tan faster? What does true love feel like? why you need problem solving skills What time does ups deliver in my zip code? what is the difference between transformation and conjugation? How long does it take toget sns with tips? how to improve my typing speed free How to perform tf2 spy butterfly knife tricks? what is an advice column template what is the definition of selflessness How to program a universal remote? Tips on how to draw blood? how to make your dribbling skills better what is the definition of trauma What does lightheaded mean? How to open clipboard? what advice would you give about applying to high school what do studies on infant speech perception show about infant language skills which hamburger helper goes best with fresh mushrooms added how to use social media to improve seo How long does it take for monistat 1 to work? what is the difference between works cited and references Why are the tips of my peace lilly turning brown? How to answer the question tell me about yourself? what benefits do i get with 50 va disability where is the helper and killer t cells located how do skills work in pathfinder rimworld how to increase skills pathfinder what skills does a ruler have? what are some skills you learn as navy seals what are the benefits of lifetime fitness what is the difference between a psychologist and a psychotherapist What does under the weather mean? what advice does the blockalteste offer elie Why are the tips of my toes always red? how to enroll in amex platinum benefits What time does the outer banks come out? How to change steam name? who to call for advice on social security benefits fort payne al What is the real meaning of pendejo? What does divine feminine mean? when tears just wont stop falling medical advice How to change ip address? How to help razor burn? over the phone advice on how to help bipolars what is the difference between wood filler and wood putty What is the meaning of apropos? What does ppl mean in texting? how long after going dairy-free will i notice a difference What is the meaning of president's day? Why wont my right foot stay on my pedal when i do tricks bmx? What does knight mean? what is the difference between npi and pii How do you cook steak tips? what is the difference between ct scan and pet scan highly sought after skills and where to get them fire emblem heroes 5 tips how to lose weight in your hips and thighs? How to connect dual monitors? how to teach leadership skills to adults what is a key island definition why are helper t cells necessary for both cell mediated and antibody mediated immunity? How to take pulse? What does location not available mean? What is the meaning of a pink evil eye? how to describe help desk skills what is the difference between walking and hiking what are the benefits of paid parental leave for society How to set up paypal? How to inhale? Street magic tricks how it's done? what are some critical skills needed to be successful in college and beyond Why do babies stare at me spiritual meaning? What does the mockingbird symbolize? What are symptoms of pink eye? How to get a job at interview tips/f/? What does mining bitcoins mean? what are the benefits of nectarines What does gender fluid mean sexually? How are most card tricks done? what are the benefits of good dental health What is the meaning of excruciating? how to say i can be a classroom helper in spanish What time does peacemaker come out? How long does it take to fully charge a tesla? What does deck mean? what is the difference between morals and ethics? what is a webinar definition what are the benefits of opening a business account