Are Light Weights Better For Building Muscle Than Heavy Weights?

Does light weight build muscle

Lose Weight / April 26, 2023

  1. New research on the growth of type I and II fibers suggest we may have been selling our slow-twitch fibers short by only training heavy.
  2. Type I fibers are maximally stimulated with longer duration sets requiring lower loads. Type II fibers respond best with short sets with heavy weights.
  3. There are a lot of ways to vary intensity in your program, like periodizing training rep ranges over time, as well as using heavy weights with multi-joint exercises and using lighter weights with single-joint movements.

"Lift heavy to grow" is a favorite mantra of coaches and gym rats alike. Heavy weights maximally recruit the large motor units associated with type II fibers, and since the type IIs are strength-related fibers with the greatest growth potential, focusing on their maximal recruitment is the key to getting swole, right?

Well, not so fast.

Don't Short-Change Your Slow-Twitch

Type I fibers are like the Rodney Dangerfield of the bodybuilding world – they get no respect. Slower, weaker, and often smaller than their fast-twitch counterparts, the type I's only claim to fame is an ability to contract repeatedly, albeit without much force.

Relegated to a life of 5K's, marathons, and unsettlingly tight running shorts, at first glance this fiber type's ability to resist fatigue seems to be more of a bodybuilding curse than a blessing. As such, training philosophies typically revolve around stimulating and annihilating the type II fiber, with little consideration for the lowly slow-twitch fibers.

However, new research on the effects of different training intensities and the growth of type I and II fibers suggest we may have been selling our slow-twitch fibers short and, in the process, missing out on pounds of potential muscle (1).

It's time to re-think our training philosophies in the context of fiber-type specific hypertrophy.

Big Weights and Type II Fibers

Certainly, a wealth of studies suggest type II fibers do, in fact, grow more with high intensity strength training (2). The caveat here is "high intensity." It's not necessarily that type II fibers have an innate ability to outgrow their slow-twitch relatives, but that they show superior growth when trained at higher intensities (>50% 1RM).

Our current understanding of the hypertrophy of each fiber type may be more a consequence of the way we've studied them (high intensity) than what actually happens in the gym (2, 3). The best summary of this relationship is a 2004 paper from Dr. Andrew Fry, who compiled the data from various studies on the growth rate of fiber types and found that, at most training intensities, the type II fiber reigns supreme.

As training intensity decreased below 50% 1RM, the type I fibers eventually outgrew the IIs, but the rate of growth in this range was still nowhere near what was achieved at higher intensities, regardless of fiber type. After reading a study like this, not much would change in our training recommendations, but there are limits to the type of analysis (regression) performed by Fry (2).

The biggest limitation is that there just weren't that many low-intensity training studies out there to compare (2, 3), and a paucity of any that directly compared high-intensity against low intensity training while accounting for growth of the different fiber types.

Add to that recent evidence on the growth rates of muscle fibers in response to differing training intensities (1) and you'll soon see that our type I fibers are capable of more than we give them credit for.

The Case for Type I

While they may be rare, there are enough studies for us to infer we've probably underestimated the hypertrophic capacity of our type I fibers. Recently, Mitchell et al. (1) performed a now infamous training study demonstrating that, when taken to failure, training with low loads (three sets at 30% 1RM) can produce comparable hypertrophy to training at higher intensities (three sets at 80% 1RM).

Looking at the individual fiber types, while the data may not be statistically significant, we see that the type I fibers responded slightly more to low intensity training (19% change versus 14%) and type II fibers more to the high intensity training (15% versus 12%).

Ultimately this suggests there's more to the equation than the number of plates you have on the bar and tentatively supports what may be intuitively obvious: Type I fibers are maximally stimulated with longer duration sets requiring lower loads, while Type II fibers respond best to short sets with heavy weights.

A common complaint with most training studies is that the researchers use untrained college students. What happens in these guys' underdeveloped physiques may not represent what would happen in highly trained muscle. Fortunately, when we look at the muscle fibers of various trained athletes, we see support for our fiber type hypertrophy theories.

Bodybuilders typically emphasize volume, fatigue, and use moderate repetition ranges (4), while their powerlifting (5) and Olympic weightlifting counterparts emphasize load and/or movement speed. Not surprisingly, bodybuilders display significantly greater hypertrophy of type I fibers compared with the strength-oriented athletes (2).

Taking all evidence into account, it seems reasonable to conclude that differing training intensities can produce comparable whole muscle hypertrophy (1, 6-8), but the fiber-types affected may differ.

As with most things in the scientific world, it's not a cut and dried issue. Two additional studies have investigated this topic – albeit with slightly different designs – and both found high-intensity training to be superior for growth irrespective of fiber type (9, 10).

Here's where it gets interesting. While there are exceptions, studies that equate work between high and low intensity conditions tend to favor high-intensity training for both fiber-type specific and overall muscle growth (10, 11). Those that don't match the work performed between conditions find equivalent results across training intensities.

How to get rid of under eye bags? What are the building blocks of proteins? How to shave pubic hair? What does expression mean? How to make chilaquiles? What does hybrid mean in a car? What does moq mean? Who jah bless no man can curse meaning? What does tv ma mean? How to go form foried to dating with these10 flirting tips? What does it mean to be content? What is clinical psychology? How to treat high testosterone in a woman? What time does academy open today? What does cwt mean? Why american tips are not white? How to do tricks in gta 5? What is the meaning of triglycerides? What is the meaning of hearse? Tips on how 2 clean your room? How to grill pork tenderloin tips? Tips on how to cover acne with makeup? How to undo on keyboard? How to count cards in blackjack? What are the seven kingdoms in game of thrones? How to change goals on apple watch? Why are cotton swabs called q tips? What does annulled mean? How to make bombs? How to add more data tips in matlab figure? What is the meaning of unwell? How to find subscriptions on iphone? What form of listening ascribes meaning to audible sounds? How to improve grip strength? How to blonde the tips of hair? How to use math in tricks psi mod? What does hsv2 look like? Burn in body skin and itching what i can do some home tips? What time is nascar on today? What does it mean when it rains on your birthday? What does r mean in baseball? How to take tips off at home? What are the grey tips on sparklers? How to add tips that aren't on w2? What do jedi tricks not work on? python what is a helper function How wake up earlier tips? How to make cucumber salad? What does amg mean? What is the meaning of bond? What is narcissism? How to get rid of mange on dogs? What is vitamin a? What does discontent mean? Tips on how to get better at football? What does the name zachary mean? How long to smoke steak tips? What is the meaning of second-degree murder? What does it mean when a dog eats grass? What is the meaning of j'adore? How to take off apple watch band? What does ti amo mean in spanish? How to dunk? What order to learn skateboard tricks? What is the meaning of the word exorbitant? How to trade pokemon go? What is the meaning of acclimated? What does psychopath mean? How to study for math 110 final tips? How to block your number? How to turn off csgo tips? What is no nut november tamil meaning? How to get out of incognito? How long does chicken take to boil? how to disable the ip helper service in windows 10 How to charge for beer and tips at event through squarespace? What does a cyst feel like? How to make flour tortillas? What time is state of the union 2022? Tips how clean clothing stain? How to do tricks on a coleman mini bike? What does obo mean on facebook? What does woof mean? how are helper t cells activated ab What does blood clot mean in jamaican? How to do balisong knife tricks? What does confidentiality mean? What are large blind spots on trucks called? Who are you song meaning? what does cd4 do in t helper cells What does it mean when you dream you are pregnant? Tricks how to get pregnant? How to increase blood flow to pennis naturally? What does rimming mean? What is low iron? What kind of personality does constant little tricks and bad things to you? What does zealous mean? What does bird dogging mean? What does exile mean? How to keep your virgin clean and smelling good? What size are childrens crutch tips? What channel is the lakers game on? What does valuable mean? How to print out tips from shortcuts? What are some small tips to determining wether an acid or base is strong vs weak? How to do dirbling tricks on 2k15? What does mi amor mean? Your kid smokes. now what? here are tips and resources for helping your child quit smoking.? How to disable pop up blocker on iphone? How to use zoom? How old do you have to be to drive? What flyers player has 3 hat tricks against the flames? How to make a ribbon bow? What is the spiritual meaning of the number 111? Which color is different tips? How to reset ipad? Tips on how to catch lake erie perch? What mouse does tenz use? How to make carrot cake? What does blue waffle mean? How to do a pull up? Getaway planning tips how prepare? What does geriatric mean? What does gerd feel like? How to prepare a new york strip steak tips tricks rest salt? How much is it to put tips on? How to deal with mean people? how much meat for hamburger helper What tips do you have from when you trained your dog? What does transparency mean? What is the meaning of duly noted? How to tell if abscess is healing? What does 30 chance of rain mean? How to make dango? Show me how to do magic tricks? How to factory reset macbook pro? What does otl mean? hearthstone arena helper what does ** mean How to get a bigger dick? How to get free shipping minimum return tips hacs=ks? How to teach dogs tricks nintendogs? How long does it take to get to mars? How to get rid of wasps with vinegar? How to get health insurance? What does scoff mean? Do you know where you're going to lyrics meaning? How to customize a blog for hacking tricks? What are fall vegetables to plant? How to wear a bandana in your hair? When things change inside you things change around you meaning? How to get rock-hard erections and last 30 minutes or more (unusual tips)? What next meaning? What does the bottom number of bp mean? What is the meaning of laundering money? Some tips on how to get your 6 year old cousin a girlfriend? Tips to how homogenize large amounts of cells? Kane brown what if song meaning? What are secondary reinforcers? whats google update helper and how can i update it What is an executive summary? What do sxsw mean? What does chula mean? How does making tips works on chaturbate? What is the meaning of papi chulo? What does mbn mean in text? What is the meaning of the word “pageant” in this context? How did the industrial revolution change the common meaning of family? What episode does luffy use gear 1? Tips on how to do a speedpaint? What does it mean when your poop is white? What does acquaintance mean? What does double action mean? How to write feet and inches? What does butternut squash taste like? What does 1437 mean in texting? What disease does brad paisley have? What does etiology mean? What does winky mean in the uk? How to beat 2048 tips and tricks? What does saint patrick's day mean? t-helper and t-killer cells recognize and bind to what on b-cells and somatic cells What time does rick and morty air? how much do you pay mother's helper What is the meaning of the name paul? How to inject a turkey? What does sentiment mean? What is the meaning behind bts euphoria? How to clean a toaster? How to add a column in excel? How to transfer contacts from iphone to android? How to cook short ribs in the oven? How to take booty pics? What is the meaning of as the crow flies? How to beat cliff may 2021? Tips on how to memorize a poem? What does cpr mean? What is the meaning of my zodiac sign cancer? How to calculate how long you have had lice? How to dry brush skin? How to restart iphone 13 pro max? How to make green dye in minecraft? Who you rooting for meaning? What is physiatrist meaning? How to do the add yours on instagram? What does vader mean in german? how do i remove spotify web helper? How to write a character reference? What are miranda rights? What do humble yourself mean? How to increase sodium levels? How to express a dog's anal glands? What does ionized mean? What is the meaning of consecutive? How to draw anime comic tips and tricks? How to practice tricks indoors? How to get rid of roaches in apartment? when do t cell differentiate to helper or cytotoxic In the video, what does the officer recommend you do if it's dark outside during the traffic stop? How to program a spectrum remote? How to harvest lavender? How to stop stuffy nose? What does oms mean in texting? How long does it take for weed to get out of your system? How to play freecell? Sahm blogs where they give you frugal tips? What does brisk mean? How to cook trader joe's steak tips? Why are tips mushroom shaped? What does ratify mean? What are the first signs of cirrhosis of the liver? What tree has seven tips on its leaves? For most interview situations, which of the following tips will serve you well? How to get rid of black neck? What does google own? What is the meaning of iso 27001? How to do a bun? What is gist mean? How to get rid of stomach gas? What does reluctant mean? What does orion mean? What does irs pay for tips? What does edm mean? What is a swift code? How to cook teriyaki steak tips in the oven? How to see who is stalking your facebook profile? What does cranberry juice do sexually? What are tips you can do to conserve water in outside your house? What does aic stand for? Why do stray cats rub against your legs spiritual meaning? How much of declared tips are taken out of paycheck? What does a white heart mean from a girl? What are ingrown hairs? How to do magic tricks with a pen youtube? What are all the love languages? What does supplementary mean in math? Tricks to tell if meat is cooked when color blind? how to get video download helper to connect to these are produced by helper t cells and determine which heavy chain class is produced by b cells Two asian guys show how tricks are done original? How to make cinnamon sugar? How to do butterfly tricks simple? What are u up to meaning? To improve your nonverbal communication, which of the following tips should you practice? how to make homade helper youtube How to play gomoku? How to w? How are tips taxed federally?